French parliament eyes plan for govt to pay for all abortions


AFP Photo / Alain Jocard

AFP Photo / Alain Jocard

French lawmakers have passed legislation that will fully finance abortions for women and provide free contraception to minors. The bill is part of President Francois Hollande’s new social security budget and will come into effect in 2013.

On Friday, the French lower house of parliament passed a bill stipulating, “women who want to stop an unwanted pregnancy have the right to be covered.” The legislation will now go through to the Senate, where it is likely to be passed in November.

French Health Minister Marisol Tourine championed the legislation, and hailed its passage as a “historic move,” adding that the “act of abortion is never a trifling matter” for women.

Under the new bill, the French state will also provide minors with free contraception in the hopes of “lifting the financial barrier impeding girls younger than 18 from access to contraception.”

Under current French law, minors are the only group that receives full reimbursement from the National Health Service for abortions, while adult women are refunded up to 80 percent of abortion costs, often amounting to over 450 euros ($580). The new measures are estimated to cost the French taxpayer an extra 31.7 million euros ($50 million).

Feminist groups hailed the step as a significant advance for women’s rights in France.

“This is a very important move, especially for women who are in the most precarious position without health coverage,” family planning secretary Marie-Pierre Martinet said. She pointed to a general indifference to abortion by French doctors and hospitals as worrying, saying that there was a shortfall of medical centers offering abortion.

One prominent critique of the new bill was the government’s failure to address access to abortion services in France. President Hollande has pledged to eliminate the issue by obliging “every medical institution to open an abortion clinic.”

Jacqueline Fraysse, a member of the French Communist Party, decried the frequent delays for abortion services in French hospitals. He cited waiting lists of up to five weeks for the procedure, well beyond the recommended five days.

Moreover, some politicians have argued that tackling the lack of education among minors concerning safe sex would reduce abortion rates.

“The 100 percent reimbursement of abortion is a quick-fix solution, what needs to be improved is the accessibility to medical facilities and professionals because girls of 15 to 18 years don’t need contraception, what they need is information,” a general delegate of The National Network of Student Relations explained to French newspaper Le Figaro.

­

‘An explosion of abortions among minors’

In the run-up to the French presidential election in May of this year, then-candidate Hollande pledged to introduce the abortion amendments to the social security budget. Presidential rival Marine Le Pen of the right-wing Front National Party attacked the legislation, arguing it would lead to an “explosion of abortions among minors.”

However, according to data collected by the French Ministry of Health, the number of abortions for minors in France has steadily decreased over the few years. In 2011, 11,670 abortions for minors were carried out, compared to 11,930 in 2008 and 12,855 in 2006.

France is currently one of the only countries in the European Union that allows minors to have abortions without any parental consent and was also the first country to permit the use of RU-486, which terminates pregnancy by causing the embryo to detach from the uterine wall.

Abortions may up Risk of Mental Health Issues


Women who undergo abortions are at greater risk of suffering from mental health problems compared with others, a new study has claimed.

The study, carried out by American academic Priscilla Coleman and published in the British Journal of Psychiatry, also claimed that one in ten of all mental health problems was a result of abortion.

There is also a greater possibility that abortion may led to alcoholism, drug abuse and suicide, said the study, which is endorsed by the Royal College of Psychiatrists.

It adds to past research published by the journal three years ago which questioned the assumption of abortion campaigners that terminating a pregnancy reduces rather than increases the health risks to women, the Daily Mail reported.

The new research was based on an analysis of 22 separate projects which together analysed the experiences of 877,000 women, of whom 163,831 had had an abortion.

It found that abortion was linked with a 34 per cent greater chance of anxiety disorders, and 37 per cent higher possibility of depression, the Daily Mail reported.

Abortions was also linked with more than double, or 110 per cent, greater risk of alcohol abuse, a three times greater (220 per cent) risk of cannabis use, and 155 per cent greater risk of trying to commit suicide, the study claimed.

It said: “Results indicate quite consistently that abortion is associated with moderate to highly increased risks of psychological problems subsequent to the procedure.

“Overall, the results revealed that women who had undergone an abortion experienced an 81 per cent increased risk of mental health problems, and nearly 10 per cent of the incidence of mental health problems were shown to be directly attributable to abortion.”

Prof Coleman has been the frequent target of pro-choice campaigners in the US for her insistence that abortion is linked to poor mental health.

Though critics have doubted her methods, they has so far been failed to damage her academic reputation, and publication in the peer-reviewed British journal is a signal that the psychiatric establishment is now taking seriously the possibility that abortion is a cause of anxiety, depression, alcoholism, drug abuse and suicide.

The new findings are certain to cause controversy at a time when the pro- and anti- abortion lobbies are in the midst of a vicious row.